Start a Reservation

We are sorry, the site has not properly responded to your request. Please try again. If the problem persists, please Contact Us .<{{vm.code}}> Reference Number <{{vm.referenceNumber}}>
You are successfully logged in. We have re-started your reservation to ensure your profile preferences are included.
{{vm.errMsgPast}}

Note: Rates are calculated based on details you provide. Some modifications may change your rate, and if so, the Car Selection page will redisplay.

Your Coupon can't be used for this reservation. Learn Why
Your promo code is invalid. Learn Why
View/Modify your reservation

Location Details

Policies
Hours:

The Payless Car Rental at HMI Auto Care in Hackettstown is located in a busy commercial and residential area just south of Route 46. This rental site is right by the city hall and other major landmarks, so you will have no trouble finding whatever you need. Main Street spans the entire length of town and hosts a variety of local dining and shopping sites. With the outstanding perks and savings offered by Payless, you will have enough funds left over to visit any of these places that interest you. There are many other car rental services around, but none of them can match our discounts.

The town is nestled between the Musconetcong River and a smaller stream to the west, with a scenic natural area to the north. Set aside a few hours to a day so you can explore Stephens State Park, the premier hiking and fishing getaway in the area. A trek along the Highlands Trail will give you a clear view of the river as well as the natural beauty of the park. If you're daring, you can even go camping here. Once you get an idea of the town's geography, learn more about its history at the Hackettstown Historical Society. It's just a few short blocks from Payless Rent a Car. In addition, we are just a few miles away from Waterloo Village, a beautiful canal town that takes you back in time to the 19th century. As for dining, try an all-American breakfast at Stella G's and sample some fresh-baked delights. If you crave Italian food and a bit of entertainment, visit Mama's Cafe Baci on the weekend and listen to live music.

If you're still not sure if Payless Car Rental is your best option, consider the many benefits of joining our Perks Club. Becoming a member won't cost you anything, and you will receive instant savings on our already-low rates. In addition to added promotions, we will save your information so it's much easier for you to book again in the future. If you want to make the most of our convenient booking process, make a reservation online at least 24 hours before picking up your rental car.

Hackettstown could be your next travel destination, and we would love to help you find your way around. With Payless, you will save more money on travel than ever before. We can't wait to hear from you!